New Zealand Law Society

Navigation menu

High Court dismisses loans firm’s appeal and notes “cynical and extortive” conduct

27 February 2019

The High Court at Auckland has dismissed Budget Loans Ltd’s appeal against the sentence imposed on it and Evolution Finance Ltd (together, Budget Loans).

The Commerce Commission says, in dismissing Budget Loans’ appeal, Justice Moore said the offending was “among the most serious of its kind. There is no comparable case involving such damaging, prolonged, focused, cynical, personal and economic conduct.”

In May 2018 Budget Loans was fined $720,000 in the Auckland District Court on 125 charges under the Fair Trading Act 1986 relating to misrepresentations made by the company while collecting loans. It was also ordered to pay reparation totalling $109,000.

  • 83 charges were for misrepresentations about the companies’ right to repossess borrowers’ property. For example, company notes on one file state “great idea to undertake an illegal repo of a vehicle”.
  • 29 charges were for misrepresentations that the companies could add costs after borrowers’ property had been repossessed and sold. For example, one borrower was told she owed more than $57,000 when a court judgment meant the balance was capped at $15,000.  The borrower declared bankruptcy as a consequence.
  • 10 charges were for misrepresentations about the amount that borrowers were required to pay under attachment orders made by the courts. For example, one borrower was told she owed nearly $56,000 when a court judgment meant the balance was capped at about $8,600.

The charges were based on a random selection of 21 debtors from loan books covering about 7,500 loans.

Justice Moore described Budget Loans’ instructions to collection agents as “cynical and extortive” and said “unlawful representations were a central feature of the companies’ operating business model.”

He noted that reparation orders had not been complied with, and “given the parlous circumstances of most, if not all of the victims, this circumstance sits uncomfortably with any suggestion on the part of the companies that they have co-operated.”

The Commission says it is seeking management banning orders against Budget Loans’ current and former directors Allan Hawkins and Wayne Hawkins.

Last updated on the 16th September 2019